Michelangelo Antonioni’s L’Avventura Proves a Game Changer for Monica Vitti and Cinema
Signaling
a stylistic shift in cinematic storytelling from the straightforward narrative
accustomed to filmgoers, 1960’s L’Avventura boldly unfolds an
unconventional, challenging tale in an often-impenetrable manner, with director
Michelangelo Antonioni putting his highly original mark on the production,
offering audiences a viewing experience unlike any seen before onscreen.
Depicting the mystery surrounding the disappearance of a wealthy young woman, Anna,
after she, her boyfriend Sandro and other cosmopolitan friends take a jet-set type
yachting excursion to the Mediterranean island of Lisca Bianca, and how this
impacts the relationships of those near her left literally asea concerning her
fate, the film and its crafty screenplay by Antonioni, Elio Bartolino and
Tonino Guerra provides audiences no easy answers in unveiling the circumstances
surrounding Anna’s vanishing, and why subsequent events play out the way they
do. Beautiful black and white cinematography by Aldo Scavarda that weaves
on-location Italian environs such as Rome and Sicily into the plot, an
evocative score by Giovanni Fusco and nicely modulated performances,
specifically by the elegant Monica Vitti in her breakthrough role as Anna’s
best friend Claudia, aid in keeping the movie’s mesmerizingly enigmatic tone at
the forefront of each artful sequence.
With
ingenuity and skill Antonioni shows great talent in creating a new method to
illustrate plot situations and the interactions between characters via his
revolutionary visual style and break from traditional storytelling norms. Using
interesting camera angles, which includes bringing cast members into view in
surprising fashion, startling close-ups that sometimes cut off facial features,
and incorporating often sparse dialogue in scenes wherein the focus is on the
players’ simply looking at each other or at figures in an ambiguous manner as
they ponder the state of their affairs, Antonioni allows one to gain an
individual interpretation as to the feelings and motivations of each character,
possibly based on the viewer’s own personal experiences. He also explores the
transitory nature of relationships in a modern, mature way, without clearly
spelling out why a person dealing with tragedy might quickly move on and fall
in love with someone else, as in the case of Claudia and Sandro, or how early
on Anna might suddenly feel disassociated from Sandro for no articulable
reason, while still feeling passion and love for him.
Antonioni also frames scenes and
dialogue to increase the intrigue of the piece, such the moment when a character
states a boat was heard in the vicinity of the island around the time of Anna’s
disappearance, then later showing four young men interrogated who were found on
a boat in the area, without it being clear if the first boat might be the same
one mentioned earlier, or another that could have taken Anna away. Following
his major critical success with L’Avventura, Antonioni would solidify
his place as a leading voice in international film during the next two years
with La Notte and L’Eclisse, his follow-up films that also
feature Vitti and serve as a trilogy of sorts with L’Avventura, then after
1964’s Red Desert with Vitti, go team with renown producer Carlo Ponti
for his biggest worldwide success with the modish, London-based and Swingin’
Sixties’ flavored Blow-Up, which also featured inscrutable plot elements
that captured audiences imaginations, helping the film and Antonioni to b box
office and critical rewards, with Blow Up awarded the top prize at
Cannes and the newly-established National Society of Film Critics, with
Antonioni winning Best Director from the later organization, and Oscar
nominations for his direction and screenplay. Following this peak, Antonioni
and Ponti reaped lesser returns with their next two English-language
undertakings, Zabriskie Point and The Passenger, before the
director completed three more films, including his final work, the 1995
all-star anthology Beyond the Clouds, the same year he was bestowed a
richly deserved honorary Academy Award, before his passing in 2007 at 94.
As Claudia, the cool, statuesque
Monica Vitti, Antonioni’s partner and onscreen muse, comes through as the
perfect heroine and camera subject to convey a variety of moods, effectively
combining a distinct, ethereal presence with one of a more direct and playful
nature, depending on the requirements of a given moment. Vitti portrays
Claudia‘s bond to Anna and her despondent nature over the loss of Anna with a
resourceful, fluid acting approach. Later, as Claudia becomes the object of
Sandro’s affection, Vitti shows the clear conflict between the young woman’s
attraction to and need for Sandro’s love, and her guilt and feelings of
unfaithfulness towards Anna if she chooses to willingly succumb to his embrace
immediately after her friend’s disappearance. In one particularly expressive
moment detailing her dramatic skill, Vitti finely demonstrates Claudia’s shift
change from giddy excitement as she fully surrenders to a love affair with
Sandro, to abrupt sullen detachment as she realizes he doesn’t share the same
passion for her. After L’Avventura, Vitti would continue as a leading
light in world cinema, gaining a host of awards for her gallery of strong,
complex women, including five David di Donatello (aka as Italian Oscar) Best
Actress prizes, while trying her hand at more assessable entertainment of the
spy genre with 1966’s English-language Modesty Blaise, making her final
film in 1989 as star and (for the only time) director of Secret Scandal before
a lengthy retirement, then passing in 2022 at age 90.
As Anna, with brief screentime Lea
Massari presents a colorful, complex character that lingers throughout the
film. Massari believably shows Anna’s impulsive nature, such as a key scene
wherein she causes havoc among the boating party’s swimmers with claims of a
shark nearby, and her restlessness concerning her bond with fiancé Sandro, and
how sturdy their relationship is, as Anna ponders a growing distance between
them, even after they become intimate again as soon as Sandro returns from a
business endeavor. Massari would build an interesting list of credits after
possibly her most famous work as Anna, including Serigo Leone’s first
directional assignment, 1961’s The Colossus of Rhodes and winning praise
for her work in Louis Malle’s Murmur of the Heart, with her final film
role coming in 1990 and her death at 91 occurring in June of 2025. Opposite
Massari, then Vitti as Sandro, the Romeo of the piece, the calm, ultra-masculine
Gabriele Ferzetti reaches one of his career peaks in a prolific film resume running
from his debut as a teen in 1942’s street of the Five Moons to his final
role in 2010, that includes Leone’s Once Upon a Time in the West, On
Her Majesty’s Secret Service and 1974’s The Night Porter. Ferzetti
lends Sandro a tellingly detached air but adds shadings to the role that make
it hard to pinpoint exactly who Sandro is, as he comes across as overly
confident at times, but also sensitive and hurt in other key moments, with
Ferzetti believably balancing the various aspects of Sandro’s comportment with
precision.
As Giulia, the pert, seemingly
uninspired young wife of an older, more intellectual husband, the doll-like Dominique
Blanchar is memorable in adding an eerie dimension to her role, first playing
up Giulia’s insipidness and sensitivity during the trip at sea then, in
stunning fashion, revealing a more carnal and harsher demeanor later in the
film, to the dismay of Claudia who witnesses Giulia’s capricious behavior. Others
blending into Antonioni’s dreamy-yet-bleak vision include James Addams as
Corrado, Giulia’s condescending husband, Esmeralda Ruspoli as Patrizia, a
sophisticated, bemused member of the voyage, Lelio Luttazzi as Raimondo, a
would-be paramour who only has amorous eyes for Patrizia during the expedition and
Jack O’Connell as the surprising and surprised inhabitant of Lisca Bianca the
party discover during their search for Anna.
The unorthodox L’Avventura created controversy at the 1960 Canne Film Festival, but due to Antonioni profound, innovative arrangement of the film’s mise en scène and its undeniable quality, which the jurors must have sensed merited recognition of some kind, the landmark film went on to gain a Jury Prize, then gained the British Film Institute’s Sutherland Trophy for its originality and imagination, Nominations for Best Film from Any Source and Best Foreign Actress for Vitti from the British Academy Awards, and landed on Time magazine’s 1961 year-end list of the top ten foreign films. After the initial release, in short order critics heralded the trendsetting masterpiece as among the most accomplished works of the cinema, with L’Avventura placing at #2, just behind Citizen Kane, on the esteemed 1962 Sight and Sound poll, then staying high on the list in subsequent decades, at #5 in 1972, #7 in 1982 and still solidly ranked inside the top 100 at #72 on the most recent 2022 survey. With the film’s uniquely framed visuals, intelligent, multi-layered performances and opaque, thought-provoking storyline and themes by Antonioni in perhaps his most consummate achievement, the influential, transcendent L’Avventura will assuredly continue to fascinate and stimulate audiences wanting a singular, unforgettable viewing excursion.