Fred Astaire and Cyd Charisse Board The Band Wagon to Cinematic Greatness
One of the primary films responsible for MGM’s reputation as
the preeminent studio behind the “Golden Age of Musicals” in the 1940s and
1950s, The Band Wagon allows two of the screen’s supreme terpsichorean
talents, Fred Astaire and Cyd Charisse, the opportunity to pair up for some of
the most memorable dancing ever seen, while Vincente Minnelli brings his
typically exceptional taste, sophistication and Grade-A utilization of those
MGM top production values to offer a visually-stunning, constantly enjoyable 1953
cinematic undertaking that constitutes one of the classiest and most indelible
entries found in the musical genre. Betty Comden and Adolph Green, at their
peak as a screenwriting team just after penning the immortal Singin’ in the
Rain, offer up another fresh, amusing, and knowing take on a show business
theme, detailing the various behind-the-scenes complications involved in
putting on a Broadway show, specifically in relation to Jeffrey Cordova, an
egomaniacal actor/director, Tony Hunter, his hoofer costar looking for a comeback,
and Gaby Gerard, the beautiful, elegant ballerina chosen for his dancing
partner and Lester and Lily Marton, the writers of the musical who also know
their way around a number. Howard Dietz and Arthur Schwartz’s great songbook is
artfully meshed with the storyline, combining classics such as “Dancing in the
Dark” (from the otherwise unrelated the 1931 revue The Band Wagon
starring Astaire and his sister Adele) and “A Shien on Your Shoes” with a new
instant showbiz anthem, “That’s Entertainment,” while Michael Kidd’s ace
chorography ensures each number is staged to the best advantage, further aiding
The Band Wagon’s status as one of Hollywood’s most sparkling musicals.
Vincente Minnelli was in the midst
of an incredible run at MGM, with a decade of quality output behind him by the
time he helmed Band Wagon. Starting with his directorial debut via
1943’s Cabin in the Sky (after years as one of the most ingenious set
and costume designers on stage and in movies) Minnelli would forge one of the
most creative and diverse filmographies, with such prime offerings as 1944’s
holiday perennial Meet Me in St. Louis starring soon-to-be wife Judy
Garland, the wonderful 1945 romance The Clock with Garland
ideally paired in a dramatic vein with the equally sensitive Robert Walker, the
inventive The Pirate, then starting the 1950s off with the one-two-three
punch of Father of the Bride, guiding An American in Paris to a Best Picture Oscar, then moving to some
florid melodrama with the Tinseltown-themed The Bad and the Beautiful. Clearly
witnessing a peak period of artistry, Minnelli brings to the Band Wagon’s
production design and the scenario rich flavor and color, while focusing on the
star performers’ abundant gifts to allow each the opportunity to shine in a
distinctive manner. Among many Band Wagon highs, Minnelli reaches an apex
with the gorgeously constructed “The Girl Hunt” set piece, an elaborate, fasted-paced
and quick-witted musical take on the popular Mickey Spillane crime novels.
Following his impeccably-crafted work on The Band Wagon, Minnelli would
continue his beneficial partnership with MGM with other notable works including
Lust for Life, a Best Director Oscar for Gigi, the same year he
staged the compelling drama of Some Came Running, Home from the Hill and
The Courtship of Eddie’s Father. After leaving the studio following yet
another hit (at least in box-office terms), the Elizabeth Taylor/Richard Buton
led (or misled) The Sandpiper, Minnelli would wrap up one of the more
substantial film careers working Babara Streisand through the large-scale movie
adaptation of On a Clear Day You Can See Forever before teaming with no
less than Ingrid Bergman and multi-talented daughter Liza for his final film,
1976’s A Matter of Time.
Band
Wagon allowed Astaire the vehicle to enter a third decade in film with his
great style and hoofing dexterity undiminished. First gaining fame as a youth
on stage with his sister Adele, leading them to triumphs on Broadway and in
London in early adulthood, after Adele’s retirement Astaire was first seen
onscreen in 1933 winging it with Joan Crawford in one of her biggest hits, Dancing
Lady, before forming the ultimate cinematic dance team with Ginger Rogers
in the same year’s Flying Down to Rio. After a string of successes,
including the peerless Top Hat and Swing Time, the professional
duo would seek careers individually in the 1940s, with Astaire first finding
his footing with the enchanting Rita Hayworth in two films, then hitting it big
opposite Bing Crosby in Holiday Inn and Blue Skies and with Judy
Garland in Easter Parade (after a brief screen retirement), before
reuniting with Rogers at the decade’s end for another sizable hit, The
Barkley’s of Broadway. Continuing fairly apace in the early 1950’s, with a
Golden Globe for 1950’s Three Little Words opposite the lovely and adept
Vera Ellen and creating one of his most famous routines dancing on the ceiling
in Royal Wedding countering the less-successful Let’s Dance and The
Belle of New York opposite Ellen, Astaire would reach the peak of his
1950’s screen endeavors with The Band Wagon. Astaire lends an easy
likability to his playing of Tony as he faces a career crossroads, while being
given ample chances to showcase his astounding singing and dancing abilities,
both in solo fashion with a rousing opening number, “Shine on Your Shoes” and later the plaintive “By Myself,” then in
truly spectacular duets with Charisse, first in their ultra-romantic traipsing
in a park to the strains of “Dancing in the Dark,” then in yowzah fashion
throughout “The Girl Hunt.” In both instances, the pair are in magical
alignment with each movement, causing a viewer to smile in admiration at the
physical perfection of their artful, unforgettable work together.
Astaire continued gracing musicals
such as Daddy Long Legs and in a welcome reteaming with Charisse for
1957’s Silk Stockings before turning to television specials, having a
major impact via his work with Barrie Chase in 1958’s An Evening with Fred
Astaire and its 1959 follow-up, while taking a dramatic turn onscreen in On
the Beach to close out the decade. With the decline of film musicals,
during the 1960’s Astaire’s screen output lessened, with 1968’s Finian’s
Rainbow offering a return to the genre, but late in his career he would finally
gain a competitive Oscar nomination (to go with his 1950 honorary Academy
Award) for charming work in one of the 1970’s disaster blockbusters, The
Towering Inferno. Seemingly as nimble as ever in his pairing with Gene
Kelly for 1976’s That’s Entertainment, Part II, Astaire would finish up
on screen (outside a documentary appearance) with 1981’s Ghost Story, before
his passing in 1988 at 88.
Cyd Charisse cemented her place as
cinema’s most beautiful and graceful presence with her electrifying dancing
skills, seizing her Band Wagon opportunities to make a lasting
impression in her signature role as Gaby, one of the first leading parts of her
career. After touring with the Ballet Russe de Monte Carlo starting at 14,
Charisse would first gain attention onscreen at MGM with Ziegfeld Follies and
1946’s hit The Harvey Girls, as the ingenue friend of Judy Garland.
Missing her big break in Easter Parade, Charisse would toil a few years
in various MGM productions, then finally gain her major breakthrough in the
all-timer Singin’ in the Rain, as the sizzling siren who woos Gene Kelly
during the climatic “Broadway Rhythm” ballet. The sensuality and magnetism
Charisse displays in this number showed her ability to act in dance as
effectively as anyone has ever done on screen, a trait that serves her very
well in her big Band Wagon moments. Opposite Astaire in “Dancing in the
Dark,” Charisse conveys a lovely, romantic persona as Gaby and Tony become
bonded, as dance partners and personally. Later, in “The Girl Hunt,” Charisse
magnificently portrays both the fragile blonde looking for protection and the
temptress who causes both Tony (in private eye mode) and the audience’s
eyebrows and temperatures to rise. Dancing doesn’t get more exciting than when
Astaire intertwines with Charisse here, whether she’s garbed in that iconic red
sequined dress while jazzing it up in a bar in perfect synchronicity with
Astaire, or moving in a gentler, poetic but equally dazzling manner as the
fetching blonde. Firmly established after Band Wagon, Charisse would
have a few good years at MGM as the studio’s premier female dancer, costarring
with Gene Kelly in Brigadoon and It’s Always Fair Weather, highlighting
Meet Me in Las Vegas with a stirring “Frankie and Johnny” number before
another peak opposite Astaire in Silk Stockings (possibly her best
performance, with several standout numbers) and again offering maximum sex
appeal in movement via Party Girl. After the 1950s Charisse’s film
output would slow down, with 1952’s Two Weeks in Another Town and
classing and steaming up 1966’s The Silencers with her undiminished
allure and dancing aptitude standing out. Moving more into television
appearances in the 1970s and 1980s, Charisse would make a fitting final big
screen appearance as one of the stars presenting in 1994’s That’s
Entertainment, Part III, before her death in 2008 at 86.
As the flamboyant Jeffery Cordova,
veteran British star of stage and film Jack Buchanan takes his late-career
showcase and makes an indelible mark, infusing the picture with his breezy,
good-natured performance style, lending distinction and verve to his duet with
Astaire and selling his part of “That’s Entertainment” with brio. Buchanan had
earlier starred in Ernst Lubitsch’s 1930 Monte Carlo before making a
name for himself in British films, allowing The Band Wagon to serve as a
fitting bookend to his other most notable Hollywood work. As the Martons, a
performing/playwriting team inspired by Comden and Green, Oscar Levant and
Nanette Fabray also add plenty of zest. As Lester, Levant is more genial than
his normal acerbic self that scored in pictures such as Humoresque and
Minnelli’s American in Paris, while Fabray gets to join Astaire and
Buchanan for the film’s funniest number, “Triplets,” while also demonstrating
the musical comedy gifts that made her a Tony-winning hit on Broadway via her
“Louisiana Hayride” solo. Fabray would go on to greater success on television,
winning three Emmys in the process, with The Band Wagon lingering as her
finest screen outings. In other roles, Ava Gardner can be seen at her loveliest
in a cameo as herself, the handsome and agile James Mitchell works so well as
Charisse’s choreographer that they re-teamed the following year for one of Deep
in My Heart’s best segments, an erotically-charged dance, while the
lithesome Julie Newmar makes an early screen appearance in “The Girl Hunt”
ballet.
Debuting at NYC’s Radio City Music Hall in July of 1953, the film’s sophisticated humor, class production design and artful numbers found great favor at the Hall and other metropolitan venues critics, while faring decently in “the sticks,” leading to The Band Wagon to amass a solid but (given the film’s high quality and production costs) not spectacular $2,550,000 in film rentals, according to Variety. Critics roundly praised the stellar efforts of The Band Wagon cast and crew, including Newsweek magazine, which placed Astaire and Charisse on the cover as part of an overview of the movie. Despite the somewhat lukewarm initial audience reaction, time has held the film in high esteem as one of Hollywood’s most entertaining and durable musicals, with the picture making the 1995 National Film Registry list for preservation, coming in at #17 on the 2006 AFI list of greatest musicals, and having no less a film historian than Martin Scorsese ranking the Band Wagon as his favorite musical. Those interested in catching benchmarks in the careers of Minnelli, Astaire, Charisse, and nearly everyone else associated with the sterling Band Wagon need make no delay in hopping aboard for a trip through one of the cinema’s most enjoyable song-and-dance ventures.
And a fond farewell to Polly Holliday, who died September 9th at age 88. A native of Jasper, Alabama, Holliday would hone her craft on stage in college and beyond before transitioning to films and television, wherein she became a true cultural phenomenon playing sassy waitress Flo Castleberry on the hit comedy series Alice, putting over one of the most famous catchphrases of the 1970s whenever the forthright Flo told her boss at Mel‘s Diner to “Kiss my grits!” Quickly establishing herself as a major character player via Flo, which would win her Emmy nominations and a couple Golden Globes, after her benchmark success on Alice and the inevitable spinoff, Flo, Holliday would continue in television, stage and film, wherein she would score another indelible role as the cantankerous Ruby Deagle, who is served one of the screen’s more memorable exits in the 1984 smash Gremlins, while also making impressions in other high-profile movies such as All the President’s Men, Mrs. Doubtfire and The Parent Trap before her final film role in 2010’s Fair Game. Rest in peace to a unique comic presence who claimed a major generational impact on audiences, Polly Holliday.